After visiting this edublogger - http://www.ahistoryteacher.com/wordpress/
, I was struck by the evangelical tone of this particular advocate for technology in education. Here is a person truly inspired by a vision for world change, for progress, for the spread of the "good news" of technological innovation. One teacher at a time, he would have "those thousands of teachers" still bound to the "industrial revolution model of education" transformed into enlightened innovators integrating the "latest" into their lessons. But as this blogger himself asks, "where are they/we all going"?
It is little wonder that this blogger, faced with the realities of modern education, is not very optimistic in the realization of his vision. Worldwide, or even nationwide, change is indeed a tall order, especially when the expectations are so high. But what sort of change might this be? This blogger is not the first to tap into the deep impulse for change. Progressives of a century ago also had a vision of a better world, a heaven on earth realized by means of governmental action. Nor were Progressives all that unique, as the enlightened leaders of the French Revolution also professed their faith in rational, scientific solutions to the ills of the world. The impulse for change and progress is in fact rooted in a Christian ethos, one that values man's self-perfection. The Enlightenment and its children simply replaced a transcendent heaven with an earthly and secularized one. Yet the desire for perfection remains, and the advocates of progress put great faith in human action and innovation to bring about this perfection on earth. Heaven is either too abstract or simply non-existent to the proponents of a melioristic view of history (belief that the world is just getting better and better), and a material world that can be scientifically analyzed, manipulated, and controlled serves as a much more real, immediate, and satisfying outlet for their reformist energies.
Again, where are we going? Will technology indeed lead us to a utopia? One may say that I have taken this blogger too far, blowing his assertions out of proportion. I am a philosopher of sorts, and I am thus interested in the ideological foundations of any mindset that I encounter. Perhaps this blogger was not advocating for an earthly utopia, indeed, he hardly spoke to any issues outside of education. However, I would like to follow through with his reasoning. What is present throughout his reasoning is "change for change's sake." Why is a classroom integrated with Web 2.0 better than the "industrial revolution model"? Why do the "thousands" of teachers stuck in outmoded methods need to change? I am willing to entertain arguments for these positions, but I found none. After reading this blog, I still failed to see that "really widespread institutional change needs to occur within the educational system," because no concrete examples were offered for what was lacking. Perhaps there are deficiencies (and I think that there are), and it would seem to be a very relevant thing for this blogger to point some of them out, and to enlighten us as to why they are deficiencies.
Moreover, I am rather unclear as to how technology is the answer to the problem of effective teaching. Is it because technology is relevant, or perhaps because it is always changing and thus will keep us on the continual road of progress? But progress to what? This blogger obviously has a vision of what would constitute a better education system. He has a certain "utopian" ideal in mind based on technological innovation. Otherwise, he would not care whether or not teachers used technology, having no grounds for comparison. His basis is his faith in progress. Whether or not he has good reasons for advocating for technology, it is clear that he is marching with the army of progress and change. However, we are left wondering what we are progressing towards. What if technology represents a regress? What if education were better served with an 18th-century model, or a 15th-century model? Who says what progress is, and to what end it should tend? As a historian, I constantly come into contact with "presentism" (unswerving faith in current ways of life) and with the arrogance that comes with it. Perhaps the modern children of the Enlightenment should use their beloved reason to critically reflect on their own firmly held beliefs.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Michael,
This post deals with some of the same philosophical issues I've been trying to sort out in my own mind for some time.
Is technology a major contributor to this demise? 'Technology' has been an important aspect of human existence from the very beginning. From microliths to irrigation to the printing press to the car. Is this progress?
Whenever I think about this issue, I often look to the rise, fall, and aftermath of the Mayan civilization. The history of this single civilization has shaped my own views on the concept of progress.
Does technology mean progress? In my mind, it is not technology that promises progress; it is how one chooses to use this technology.
Your last point is very good. I am not against technology, or change, or innovation, despite my critical posts. I am rather concerned with both the uncritical approach many seem to be taking in regards to technological advancement ("if it's new, it must be good") and the very real and lasting effects that technology is having on society and the human psyche and way of life. Technology needs an ethical dimension - a moral (and not merely utilitarian) criteria for determining how best to use technology. And ethics can only be intelligible and meaningful if there is a clear end to human activity, an end that fulfills what is truly human and good.
Post a Comment